歌詞: Evan Taubenfeld. Welcome To The Blacklist Club. Pumpkin Pie.

I was fine with just hanging out
I was living like a player in a west coast town, yeah
I never thought that I would ever settle down
Always, one girl after the other
Didn't wanna be your boyfriend, all I needed was your number
Lemme share a little bit of what I found

There were so many flavors I wanted to taste

But then Jamie, I thought she was the one
But she played me just like 21
Then Katie, I couldn't get enough
She was just like pumpkin pie
And then Katie she kinda had a thing with Stacy
And that was pretty fun, but lately
I wanna go to sleep with the same girl
The same girl every night

Some girls should come with a warning
And a dose of penicillin first thing in the morning
But last night that never really crossed my mind
Always, one girl after the other
I was hitting on your roommate, I was flirting with your mother
And now I guess I'm feeling it was always like that time

Like Jamie, I thought she was the one
But she played me just like 21
Then Katie, I couldn't get enough
She was just like pumpkin pie
And then Katie she kinda had a thing with Stacy
And that was pretty fun, but lately
I wanna go to sleep with the same girl

I want the same girl every night
Who wants the same guy every night
In the same bed every night
Every single night
I want the same girl every night
Who wants the same guy every night
What a perfect fucking life
Every single night

So many flavors I wanted to taste
All those girls, well how can I forget those names
Like Jamie, I thought she was the one
But she played me just like 21
Then Katie, I couldn't get enough
She was just like pumpkin pie
But baby, you're the only one that can save me
I guess I'm in love, cause lately
I wanna go to sleep with the same girl
The same girl every night